Up and Hunt is an independent product comparison platform. We may earn a commission when you click through.
Is NYX's Jumbo Eye Pencil in 'Milk' Worth Your Money?
NYX's Jumbo Eye Pencil in 'Milk' has been a cult favorite, but does it still hold up in 2026? We dig into the details to see if this classic is still a must-have in your makeup bag.
The Quick Version
The NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil in 'Milk' is a versatile staple for bold, bright eye looks. At $8.07, it's affordable, but its performance is polarizing among users. With a 4.3-star rating from over 69,300 reviews, it’s clear this product has fans, though it's not without its flaws.
NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil, Shade: Milk
A cult classic eye pencil that’s versatile and affordable.
What's Inside
This eye pencil offers a creamy formula that can be used as an eyeshadow, eyeliner, or highlighter. The shade 'Milk' is a pure white that can brighten the eyes or act as a base to make other colors pop. It's designed to be sharpenable, ensuring you get precise lines each time you use it.
What's Actually Good
The creamy texture makes it easy to blend, and the pigmentation is impressive for a drugstore brand. It’s a multi-tasker, great for a quick eye look or as a base for bolder shadows. At just over $8, it’s a bargain for those experimenting with their look.
The Catch
While the formula is creamy, it can also be a bit too soft, leading to smudging and creasing if not set properly. Some users report that it doesn’t last all day, especially on oily lids, and the sharpenable design might be inconvenient if you’re used to twist-up pencils.
Who It's For
If you’re starting out with makeup or love experimenting with different eye looks, this is for you. It's ideal for those who want a budget-friendly product that can be used in multiple ways. However, if you have oily lids or need something long-lasting, you might want to look elsewhere.
The Bottom Line
The NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil in 'Milk' remains a versatile and affordable option in 2026. It’s not perfect, but for $8.07, it’s a fun addition to any makeup kit. Looking for more budget-friendly picks? Check out The Best Makeup Picks for Every Budget This April.
